How Can You Establish a New Identity After Leaving Christianity?

Julia Sudnitskaya/Shutterstock.com

In this post, I talk about how, if you’re leaving Christianity for spirituality, one of the five challenges you might face is establishing a new identity. This could be a challenge even if you’re leaving Christianity without knowing what’s next in terms of your spiritual life. If your identity was strongly tied to your religion, it’s possible you now find yourself in the middle of an identity crisis.

Here, I want to offer a few suggestions on how you can start to cultivate a new identity after leaving Christianity.

5 Tips for Establishing a New Identity After Walking Away from Christianity

1. Go on a self-discovery journey.

   I would encourage everyone to go on a journey of self-discovery at least once. This is because, as we live our lives, we can become so accustomed to believing certain things and doing things a certain way that we forget to ask ourselves if we’re being true to ourselves by believing these things and behaving this way.
   
   But at pivotal moments like when you’re trying to figure out who you are after setting aside what was formerly a big part of your identity, this is an ideal time to go on this type of journey. To get started, I would advise you to just search for something like “how to begin a journey of self-discovery.” You could even ask AI for help on how to start if you feel comfortable doing so.
   
   Before you begin, though, I want to remind you that this type of journey doesn’t require travel. While you can use travel to help you discover yourself, this journey is more of a journey inward. So, all that’s necessary is for you to be willing to go deep and ask yourself hard questions that you then search for answers to.
   
   The most challenging part of this self journey is to actually start living out new beliefs and ways of being or behaving. So, I would advise you to go slow with the process.

2. Get clear on what you believe.

   Religion encourages you to believe religious teachings, sometimes making it sound like those teachings are absolute truth. This is one reason it can be especially hard to let go of religious beliefs, particularly those that have been deeply held by you. But if you want to start discovering who you are without religion, you’ll probably have to unlearn many of the beliefs you were taught and replace them with new beliefs that resonate with who you are now.
   
   Some people may call this process “deconstruction,” but I prefer to think of it as belief clarification. If you need help getting started, in this post I present a six-step process for getting clear on what you believe after leaving religion. And just know, the self-discovery journey I mentioned in tip #1 can help you gain this clarity.

3. Identify your core values.

   Your core values act as a guide or compass for your life. If you’ve been deeply involved with Christianity, it’s likely that you’ve been living according to Christian values. Some of those values might actually be in alignment with your personal values, but some of them might not. Taking time to identify your core values and releasing values that you don’t or no longer hold can help you establish your identity apart from Christianity.
   
   Also note that it’s totally fine if you share some values with Christianity. The important thing now is not a complete separation of your values and Christian values. The important thing is to get clear on your personal values so you have that guide for future decision-making, rather than relying on religious teachings or religious leaders to tell you what to do.
   
   After being told what to believe and how to live for so long, getting clear on your core values can help you become more aware of what truly matters to you. Here, I present 15 journal prompts you can respond to for gaining this clarity so you can start living a more authentic life.

4. Focus on other groups you are or could be part of.

   This is a suggestion I give in the post I mentioned in the introduction about challenges you might face when shifting from Christianity to spirituality. I know that after I left Christianity, I started to identify more with my identity as someone of the INFJ personality. I’m into personality typing, and I resonate with a lot of the descriptions about INFJs and INFJ behavior.
   
   While I know that my personality type isn’t all of me, it was helpful to focus on an aspect of myself that I still felt connected to. If you’re part of a group naturally or through hobbies or other interests, try to connect more with these sides of yourself as you establish your new identity. And if you’re looking for community after leaving religion, joining groups related to these other sides of you or your interests might be a good way to start.
   
   You could even look into developing new hobbies or interests if you don’t feel like anything you’re doing right now is resonating deeply enough or isn’t allowing you to connect with others the way you would like to.

5. Be willing to experiment.

   As you discover yourself after leaving Christianity, you’ll likely have to do quite a bit of experimenting. If you’re finding it at all challenging to figure out who you are without religion, it’s probably because religion was a big part of your life and identity.
   
   You might have been used to associating mostly with Christians or working in a Christian environment or being involved in Christian activities. Establishing a new identity is going to require you to step outside your comfort zone and experiment with new identities and ways of being until you find what works for you.
   
   Be patient with yourself throughout this process. Give yourself time to figure things out as you separate yourself from what used to be a big part of your life. Be open to trying new things, believing new beliefs, and living in a new way.

Final Thoughts

Your identity is not fixed. Even if you once considered yourself a devout Christian, that part of your identity wasn’t fixed. I know that religious beliefs tend to run deep, but that doesn’t mean you can’t uproot the ones that no longer resonate with you and replace them with new ones that do.

And as you do that and gain clarity on your core values and aspects of yourself that you still feel connected to, you can establish a new identity outside of Christianity. You’ll have to be willing to do some introspection and experimentation along the way, though.

Also know that your identity can change over time as you have new experiences and come to see yourself and the world differently. But to help you start developing a solid foundation you can use to move forward right now, it can be useful to establish a new identity that allows you to live more freely and authentically. I hope the above tips help you do just that.

But if you’re finding it particularly difficult to cultivate a new identity after walking away from Christianity, I offer spiritual coaching services you might be interested in. Through these services, I help Christians navigate the transition from Christianity to spirituality. If you’re interested, simply click here to learn more.

~ Ashley C.